Woman leads mixed-gender prayer

2005 April 23rd  |

The Globe and Mail, [04/23/2005]

 

Backyard gathering of Muslims crosses ‘another threshold of conservativism’

 

APARITA BHANDARI

SPECIAL TO THE GLOBE

For Raheel Raza, becoming the first Muslim woman in Canada to lead publicly announced prayer was awe-inspiring, a “silent revolution.” And while the gathering of more than 20 men and women yesterday in the backyard of a home in Toronto’s Cabbagetown was small, the importance of the event was not lost on the worshippers.

“This is a landmark event because it crosses yet another threshold of conservatism,” said Tarek Fatah, co-founder of the Muslim Canadian Congress and whose small yard was the venue for the Juma Prayer led by Ms. Raza. “It sets an agenda where you can’t go back from here.”

Back for Mr. Fatah and others is to the belief among many traditional Muslims that women-led prayers are heretical and un-Islamic. Indeed, it was fear of confrontations that caused the traditional Friday afternoon prayer to be moved twice — from the Noor Cultural Centre and from a commercial building in downtown Toronto, after a New York-based Urdu-language newspaper published the leaked secret location — before landing in Mr. Fatah’s yard. The prayer had also been condemned as anti-Islamic.

In her manner of dress, Ms. Raza did not stray from tradition: The black shawl with red embroidery that covered her head also covered her traditional dress of long tunic and pants, resembling a burqa. One of the many reasons for segregation of men and women in prayers is the potential distraction of a woman’s sexuality.

Before addressing the gathering, Ms. Raza — who has led many inter-faith prayers at churches, temples and synagogues — went over the passages she had marked in the Koran she was clutching.

“I am in awe, and I have this responsibility. I don’t want to mispronounce anything,” she said. “This is such a significant day. Firstly, because it’s actually the day of the Prophet’s birthday. And it’s the Juma Prayer, a significant weekly ritual for Muslims. And I have been asked to lead the prayer.”
Starting with a zikr (chanting of a verse), Ms. Raza stood to read her khutba (sermon). The Juma Prayer went off without a hitch.

“It’s a very humbling experience to be asked by my own community to lead them,” she said. “This is my submission to God. This is not for people, it’s not for the media. It’s not that I want to take over the duties of male imams.

“In terms of a movement, I call it a silent revolution. Other women will hear about it and feel empowered. It’s not being equal to men. Because men can’t be equal to women. But it’s about being equal in spirituality.”

Mr. Fatah, whose MCC organized the prayer, added: “There’s a sense of solidarity with women who do feel they need to be in leadership positions, with all respect to those who don’t wish to be. There are many ways of expressing Islam. And I think this is the way the Prophet would have appreciated it, had he been alive today.”

Among those at the prayer was Asra Nomani, a former Wall Street Journal reporter-turned-author based in Morgantown, W. Va. She was in Toronto for the fifth stop on the Muslim Women’s Freedom Tour she launched on March 1 to visit North American cities, promulgating the message of women’s rightful place alongside men in Islam.

The first stop had been New York. On March 18, a mixed-gender Friday congregational prayer was led by Amina Wadud, a female Islamic studies professor at Virginia Commonwealth University. The prayer made news around the world, and the protests, as well as support, extended from the pavement outside Synod House at the Cathedral of St. John in New York to Malaysia and Egypt.

On Thursday night, hours before attending the prayer led by Ms. Raza, Ms. Nomani read from her book, Standing Alone in Mecca, for an audience at the Noor Cultural Centre. While on a pilgrimage to Mecca, she said, she was inspired by the throngs of men and women praying side by side. She spoke about losing her religion and reclaiming it from the strictures of patriarchy.

“After yesterday’s prayer, Ms. Raza and Ms. Nomani hugged. The gilt of the Arabic calligraphy on Ms. Raza’s Koran glinted in the sun.

“We did it,” Ms. Nomani said. “It was so simple. Just a few people and a woman willing to lead them. But it was so profound.”

Sufi shrine welcomes all

2004 July 3rd  |

Toronto Star, [07/03/2004]

 

Burial place of Nizamuddin open to all religions. Village around mausoleum a hub of Sufi culture

APARITA BHANDARI

SPECIAL TO THE STAR

 

New Delhi, India — It’s a difficult drive to the Nizamuddin basti or village that grew up around the mausoleum of renowned Indian Sufi Nizamuddin Aulia.

In A.D. 1274, Nizamuddin moved from his birthplace, Badauin, to Delhi, establishing a khanqah (monastery) in the jungle of Ghiyaspur, away from the main city and the politics of the royal courts. At the khanqah, Nizamuddin meditated and taught his disciples.

Over the years, the basti has become the hub of Sufi culture in the city. The annual Urs commemorating the birth and death anniversaries of Nizamuddin and his favourite disciple, poet and musician Amir Khusro, attracts thousands.

It’s fitting that the path to the dargah (shrine) of Nizamuddin isn’t easy, even if the small obstacles are modern constructs. After all, Sufis believe Sufism is covered with a veil, which you can see only through by discipline and persistence.

While colossal forts built during the same era now lie in ruins, the 700-plus-year-old dargah of Nizamuddin is one of the most popular spiritual destinations in India. Irrespective of religious backgrounds, people visit it, sometimes to have their prayers answered, and sometimes seeking inner tranquility.

On the outside, there’s nothing serene about Nizamuddin, especially the immediate surroundings of the dargah.

Touristy paragraphs describing the dargah usually talk about “going through a time-warp into the medieval period of India.” Beggars seek alms, dressed in ragged clothes, sitting along the narrow pathways leading to the centre. Shopkeepers perch on their haunches on their wooden stalls, cocooned in woollen shawls. They ply flower garlands or chadars (cloth) as you go in, and devotional books and music cassettes as you come out. The heavy scent of roses hangs in the air - the same smell of rose attar popular in bygone times.

En route, there’s a baoli (water tank) known as the Chashma-E-Dilkhusha. It’s said Nizamuddin himself started the construction of the baoli, digging with his own hands and blessing the water. His followers believe the water has mystical properties.

Following the alleys, you suddenly come into an open courtyard, and in the middle stands the dargah.
The structure is simple. Paved with marble, the dargah’s veranda has five arched openings on each side. The roof covering the arches has a parapet, topped by a series of small domes. A larger, onion-shaped dome, with alternating stripes of black and white marble, stands on top. Lattice screens and arches surround the actual tomb, forming an inner sanctum. Inside, a wooden canopy inlaid with mother-of-pearl arabesques is covered with the chadars offered to the Sufi.

The dargah is opposite the Jama’t Khana mosque, built by the son of the ruler Ala-ud-din Khilji. It’s also home to the mausoleums of Khusro, and the Mughal princess Jahanara. The mausoleums of famous Mughal ruler Humayun and celebrated poet Ghalib are also at a short distance away from the basti. It’s said that Nizamuddin Aulia was so loved that people wished to be buried near him.

The Sufis’ popularity doesn’t seem to be waning. A steady stream of people visit the dargah, some to offer prayers, others give the garlands or chadars to the Nizamis, who offer them at the dargah. The Nizamis are descendants of Nizamuddin’s sister since he, himself, never married.

A few men sit in front of the dargah. One plays the harmonium, singing a quwwali or mystic song. Another joins in a falsetto.

“Hazrat Nizamuddin was a great spirit,” says a man, in Urdu, who gives his name simply as Irfan. “People come here with their problems, but they take away peace.”

Like the incense man who sits daily at the dargah, Irfan is something of a permanent fixture at the dargah, a sort of a modern-day dervish (monk).

“Everyone remembers God in distress,” says Irfan, paraphrasing an oft-repeated Sufi couplet. “Remember Him in happiness. There will be no sadness. I like it here because we get close to God, we’re close to Nizamuddin.”

Nizamuddin Aulia (1236-1325) was the fourth saint of the Chistiya order, a lineage of Sufi saints. Sufism is passed on from the Sheikh (elder) to the disciple, and the silsila (chain of authorities) is traced back to the Prophet Muhammad.

Sufism’s history is controversial; it depends on which Muslim you talk to, says Tabith Abdullah, associate professor of history at York University.

“Those more favourable towards Sufism say that it started with the dawn of Islam, that the Prophet was a Sufi,” says Abdullah. “Others tend to view Sufism as heresy, as a foreign element that came to Islam.”

All religions have a mystical side, which is juxtaposed with a more legalistic reading of the religion, explains Abdullah. While the branch emphasizing the law specifies the dos and don’ts, the mystical side emphasizes the heart rather than the mind.

“There’s one medieval Sufi saying from Anatolia,” he says. “It says `If you’re searching for God, you won’t find Him in Mecca, you won’t find Him in Jerusalem, you’ll find Him in your heart.’”

Sufism’s heyday was between the 10th and 16th centuries when it was practised in Africa, Anatolia, Central and South Asia. It was heavily influenced by Indian mysticism, as well as the pre-Islamic religion of Iran and Mesopotamia. Recently Sufism has regained popularity, especially through the works of Sufi poets such as Rumi and Rabia.

The Sufis usually convey their beliefs through poetry and parables. Much of Sufi poetry has to do with love. To the uninitiated, the poetry might seem secular with references to the Beloved, as well as states of intoxication by partaking in wine. However, the idea is to see God as the Beloved, and the intoxication is a result of being close to God or to unite with God.

One of the practices of Sufism is zikr, or remembrance. At Nizamuddin’s shrine, zikr is done accompanied with music in the form of qawwali. Other zikr sessions have become known for the whirling dervishes.

Zikr, or for that matter, Sufism, isn’t to be equated with qawwali or the whirling dervishes, says Abdullah.

“Many Sufi brotherhoods have peculiar zikr sessions,” he explains. “The whirling dervishes, for example, developed in Anatolia. The idea is to imitate the movement of the heavenly bodies to get close to the spiritual. Singing, the use of candles, all of this has really to do with local peculiarities. Some brotherhoods just repeat passages from the Qur’an.”

Although such sessions of music and dance often elicit “polemic” from the Sharia-minded Muslims, the tension between Islam and Sufism is articulated by a much more sophisticated argument.

“The Sufis say that the word of God can have esoteric and literal interpretations,” says Abdullah. “The Sharia-minded say this is dangerous. It opens (the Qur’an) to any kind of interpretation that people like, but the truth is that the word of God is exactly what it is, just the literal meaning.”

It’s practically impossible to summarize the beliefs of Sufism once you go beyond the generalities, says Abdullah. Some Sufi saints place great importance on the Sharia, while other Sufis pay no attention to it, and there’s a whole spectrum of Sufis in between.

“Sufis like Nizamuddin taught the people to follow the Sharia, to go to the congregational prayer on Friday,” says Abdullah. “But they also suggested practising zikr, especially on Thursday evening.”

The popularity of Nizamuddin and, by extension, of Sufism in India, has something to do with the mystical aspect of the faith, but also because the Sufis’ views of religion weren’t rigid, says Abdullah.

“(The Sufis) were able to reach out to other religions because there are so many commonalities between the mystical traditions in India,” says Abdullah. “There were some Sufis who even allowed non-Muslims to join their brotherhood.”

Fasting and Feasting

2001 December 12th  |

Toronto Star

After a month of Ramadan fasting, Muslims find self-denial pays off with elaborate meals

Melt-in-your-mouth sheek kebabs (minced lamb kebabs). Deliciously fragrant biryani (rice with meat). A simpering nihari (thick gravy prepared with lamb) served with hot, hot kulche bread. Fiercely spicy baghare-baingan (stuffed eggplants). And, of course, the traditional sheer korma (almond milk drink) and seviyan (vermicelli pudding.)

Growing up Hindu in New Delhi, even I looked forward to Eid-ul-Fitr, the festival of breaking the fast at the end of Ramadan. I’d be invited to my Muslim friend Sarfaraz’s house to share the feast his mother had conjured up.

She wouldn’t bat an eyelid when a group of us showed up at her doorstep, since there was always a steady stream of people going in and out. The older ones would exchange sweets, the younger ones would get gifts, usually money, from the elders. And they, too, would partake of the food.
Ramadan is the ninth month of the lunar Muslim calendar.

During these 29 or 30 days, from one new moon to the next, the faithful fast from dawn to dusk, abstaining from food, drink, tobacco and sexual activities as long as there’s light enough to enable the eye to distinguish between a black thread and a white thread held at an arm’s length. In practice, the fast is governed by the morning and evening calls to prayer.

The morning meal must be finished before dawn. After sunset, the meal is called iftar. Those who are old, ill, pregnant or menstruating do not fast, and travellers are exempt during their journey: Some can “make up” for their missed fasts during that year. At the end of the month, each person may give a month’s ration of food to the needy. Those unable to fast may give a year’s ration.

Fasting has been, and in many cases still is, an integral part of Judaism, Christianity, Hinduism, Buddhism and the Baha’i faith. The idea of self-denial and noting one’s unworthiness in the face of God by fasting is common, whether it’s limited to a specific day or prolonged.

Fasting has also become commonplace in alternative health practices and fad diets. People undergo juice fasts and mono diets (eating a single food, like grapes) to cleanse their bodies of toxins. It’s also supposed to give the digestive system a rest.

But denying oneself sustenance, especially for religious purposes such as Ramadan, poses an inherent duality. The fast ends with a feast. The idea isn’t to gorge yourself silly, although some people do. The purpose is to share the bounty. It’s almost as if to truly appreciate the special food, you have to achieve a certain pitch of hunger.

Ramadan feasts vary from region to region. It’s customary to break the fast with a date, in the custom of Mohammed. Packed with carbohydrates, dietary fibre and natural sugars, dates are also a powerhouse of energy.

In Sudan, people drink a cup of tea to return shrunken stomachs to normal size. In Ethiopia, barley soup is easy on the stomach. Samosas and stuffed grape leaves are popular in Egypt. In India and Pakistan, the mild curries called kormas, biryani or pulao rice dishes and kebabs are common fare.

Habeeb Salloum, a Toronto freelance writer who has often visited Morocco, is enthusiastic about harira, a rich chick-pea soup traditionally served in that country to break the fast. While not a practicing Muslim, Salloum has twice observed the month-long fast on his visits to North Africa.

“Harira helps relieve the body from the day’s fasting,” he says. “And after a main course of tajine (fragrant stew), they eat bariwat, a honey-dipped sweet.”

In India and Pakistan, the popular sweets are jalebi (fried fritters dipped in a sugar syrup), kheer (rice pudding) or ice cream.

During Ramadan, Muslims invite relatives and friends to break the fast at iftar parties. It becomes a communal as well as a culinary activity. And during Eid-ul-Fitr (which will fall either Dec. 15 or 16, depending on the sighting of the new moon), people open their doors and prepare enough food to feed hundreds of guests.

The Merchant family of Thornhill used to host large iftar and Eid parties. This year, they are inviting only 14 people, including their children’s friends.

The spacious kitchen in their four-bedroom condominium is abuzz with activity when I visit recently. With an hour left before sunset, Fatima Merchant, dressed in a brown tunic and pants, directs daughter Farah and niece Rubina Nazir Ali in the kitchen.

“I usually prepare everything beforehand,” says Fatima, instructing Rubina to add lime juice to a fruit salad.

Anwar (Andy) Merchant, Fatima’s husband, hovers around the dining table, lighting decorative candles. Guests are ushered into the main living room. Shrieks of laughter can be heard from the room where the children are entertaining their friends.

The kids understand the religious significance of Ramadan but also see it as an opportunity to socialize. Most started fasting on the weekends when they were 6, building up to the month-long fasts as they grew older.

“But we always wanted to fast more than that,” says Farah. “There was a sense of accomplishment.”
Although they have no trouble fasting, they say, it can be exhausting during exam times and when Ramadan falls during the long days of summer.

“I just change my three meals around,” says Tarek Merchant, a boarder at St. Andrews College and an avid tennis player.

He eats a bigger meal at night before hitting the books and another in the morning, but continues tennis practice.

“I go after 6: 30 p.m., so it’s not bad,” he says. “I break my fast at 5 p.m., which helps me digest the food.”

Growing up in Kingston, where there wasn’t a large Muslim community, the children were often met by bewilderment from their friends.

“I hated all those ‘What if’ questions,” laughs Nadine Mouftah, Farah’s friend. “‘What if your mouth is open and a fly enters it? What if you forget?’”

They found themselves dispelling misconceptions.

“If you accidentally drink or eat something, you are still fasting,” says Syma Merchant. “It’s the intention that counts.”

Outside, the sky slowly darkens. The dinner table quickly fills up with appetizers and other dishes. There’s veal korma, mixed vegetables, chana masala (curried chick-peas), samosas, chicken wings, sheek kebabs, pita bread and hummus, potato cutlets stuffed with meat and boondi ka raita (tiny chick-pea flour dumplings in yogurt). Sitting in the middle of the table is a plate of dates, which Fatima begins to hand out.

Rubina wonders whether the salt in the food is all right. “We can’t taste the food,” she laughs.
Meanwhile, in Mississauga, children run amok in the small garden of Farah and Fahad Dawood’s house.

The Dawoods are hosting an iftar for their two children’s friends, aged 5 to 9, who attend the same Islamic school. Two of the 9-year-olds, Hamza Sanoushi and Shadman Chaudhary, are fasting on weekends, although all of them claim they are fasting too.

Farah is in the kitchen preparing the children’s favourite snacks - chicken balls and dahi-puri (wafer-thin wheat balls filled with yogurt). In the adjoining TV room, a debate rages about whether to watch Digimon or Men In Black.

“They always get invited to their parents’ iftars,” says Farah, as she lays out the table. “I thought I would have one just for the kids.”

Sometimes, Muslims break the fast with just immediate family. Shaha Husain, the woman behind the Mezban line of bottled condiments, is cooking food for her three children. Her compact midtown apartment is calm.

The table is already laid out with sliced bananas in lime juice, lentil salad, chewy flatbread, cucumbers and yogurt, a tray of dried nuts, some lemonade and a plate of dates. Samir Husain, Shaha’s son, periodically peeks in the oven at the banana tart he’s baking. “Too many bananas in the house,” he grins, hoping this recipe he just made up will turn out.

Dressed in a rust coloured silk sari, Shaha sits down and slivers almonds for chicken pulao. “This is a festive time for us because this is the month that the Qur’an was revealed to the Prophet,” she says as she wipes almond dust from the coffee table.

“The idea is to discipline yourself and understand how the needy feel. You also break habits. Keeping roze (fasts) was good for my father. He was a chain smoker but gave up smoking during Ramadan. He would continue without it for six or eight months after Eid, and then slowly get back into it.

“Your body adjusts to it,” she says. “Fasting from sunrise to sunset for 30 days is not hard if you have the willpower.”

Bustling around in the kitchen as she puts the final touches on the pulao, Shaha explains that easily digested meats such as chicken and seafood are preferred during Ramadan. Thirst-inducing garlic and salt are used minimally. A heavy breakfast is followed by fresh fruit. “Some people eat steak and eggs,” she says.

Although Zannat Mirza, a registered dietician, is dismissive of the supposed health benefits of fasting, she does advocate a smarter way to fast. She advises waking up early and eating a protein-rich meal to sustain yourself for the day.

“The key is not to overdo it, even if you are hungry. Pace yourself. Drink lots of fluids,” Mirza says. “Water, juices, milk, soup.”

Shaha, reminiscing about Ramadan in Hyderabad, capital of the Indian state of Andhra Pradesh remembers using a lot of yogurt in cooking. “It’s cooling,” she explains.

“When the sun sets, you break the fast with a little bit of food. Then you pray and have a bigger meal in the evening. It was special there. We would wait for the azan (call for prayer) and then break our fast.”

There’s no azan here, but as the sun sets, Shaha takes a date. She slowly whispers a small prayer before popping it in her mouth.